Recognition at work is not a program

Employee of the month, redeemable points, thank-you walls: why these run out of steam, and what works instead.

Kim ArsenaultUpdated July 25, 2026
Sand and blue gradient in the Inlead RH palette

We are often asked to "put a recognition program in place". The request is almost always a symptom of something else: people do not leave because a points system is missing, they leave because their manager has said nothing in eight months.

What does not work

MechanismWhy it runs out of steam
Employee of the monthRewards visibility, not contribution. Eleven losers a month.
Redeemable pointsTurns a social gesture into a transaction. Value becomes monetary, therefore comparable.
Thank-you wallFills up for three weeks, then becomes a reminder of its own abandonment.
Annual bonusToo far from the act. Nobody connects a December cheque to an effort in March.

The common thread: all of them move recognition from the manager to a mechanism. But the person is precisely what the message is made of.

The three conditions

Specific

"Good work" recognizes nothing. "Your follow-up with the client on Thursday is why we did not lose the contract" recognizes something, because it proves somebody was watching.

Fast

Recognition has a very short half-life. Past two weeks it reads as a formality rather than a reaction.

From directly up the line

A mention from the CEO is pleasant. A sentence from the direct manager changes behaviour, because that is the person who decides assignments, scheduling and the next promotion.

Where to start

The first four weeks

  • Ask every manager to name one specific contribution per person, per month.
  • Write it into the one-on-one record, so it is traceable.
  • Remove any mechanism that produces one winner and a set of losers.
  • Measure after six months with "my work gets noticed", not with a headline score.

It costs nothing, it needs no tool, and it is the only part of the problem leadership genuinely controls.

Read next